The Role of Religious–Traditional Ideas in Legitimizing Governance in Saudi Arabia

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Private Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran.

2 Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran.

Abstract
Introduction
Political systems cannot simply govern society by following the dictates of others; they therefore require at least some degree of institutional and functional legitimacy. Among Middle Eastern states, the Saudi regime, in addition to enjoying functional legitimacy—including through the provision of relative prosperity and security—continues to benefit from sources of institutional legitimacy. In this respect, the present study aimed to examine how Saudi Arabia benefits from religious–traditional sources of legitimacy.
Literature Review
The issue of legitimacy has been addressed to some extent in studies of Saudi Arabian politics and society. However, these studies have not specifically examined the role of religious–traditional concepts—such as the guardian (walī), consultation (shūrā), oath of allegiance (bayʿa), and domination (sulṭa)—in legitimizing the Saudi political system. The current study sought to fill this gap by examining how these ideas contribute to the legitimacy of the Saudi political order.
Materials and Methods
The present study used the method of textual analysis.
Results and Discussion
The governance of Saudi Arabia, characterized by oligarchic sovereignty, has engaged and continues to engage in processes of legitimization through two broad categories of legitimacy sources: religious sources and customary or traditional sources. Due to the pressures and imperatives generated by globalization, legitimacy has become a persistent concern for the hereditary rule of the House of Saud and a potential Achilles’ heel of the country’s national security doctrine.
The concept of the guardian (walī al-amr, meaning the ruler of the affairs of Muslims) and the legitimization derived from it have been widely invoked by the Saudi regime and by those who support and justify its rule. However, given the character, conduct, and political practices of the Saudi monarchy, legitimization based on this concept can be regarded as an inappropriate metaphor. Some Salafi-Wahhabi scholars, such as Mohammad al-Mass’ari, have consequently subjected the use of walī al-amr as a basis for legitimizing Saudi rule to serious criticism, rejecting the justification of the Saudi political order on these grounds.
The doctrine of dominance and overpowering (istīlāʾ wa ghalaba) provides the Saudi regime with a particularly powerful basis for legitimizing its power. From this perspective, the Saudi political order is, to a considerable extent, shielded from subversive movements and political opposition, as challenges to the ruler are portrayed as an unforgivable sin and an act against the Islamic law. The emergence, however, of jihadi and Salafi currents that challenge this doctrine constitutes an important Achilles’ heel of Saudi legitimization based upon it.
The Saudi regime has also drawn on the tradition of consultation (shūrā) and, more specifically, on the institution of the Shūrā Council to establish and consolidate the foundations of its political authority. The Shūrā Council currently serves as an institutional mechanism through which the Saudi regime invokes the principle of consultation as a source of legitimacy. Nevertheless, given the autocratic character of the monarchical system and the concentration of power within the ruling family, the consultative character of the Saudi political order appears largely symbolic and does little to promote the consolidation or institutionalization of national security.
The Al Saud regime likewise employs the concept of oath of allegiance (bayʿa) to legitimize its rule and political structure. The establishment of the Allegiance Council, composed of members of the Al Saud family and established within the Saudi political system, reflects this same approach. However, internal rivalries within the ruling family, as well as reports of coercion involving members of the royal family during the succession process that brought Mohammed bin Salman to power, constitute significant vulnerabilities in this source of legitimacy.
The endorsement of the Saudi rulers by religious scholars constitutes another important source of legitimacy upon which the Saudi regime relies. These scholars have historically been predominantly Wahhabi in orientation. For some of them, the doctrine of dominance and overpowering (istīlāʾ wa ghalaba), together with the concept of the guardian (walī al-amr), provides an important basis for endorsing the authority of the ruling family. At the same time, a number of Muslim scholars—including some who identify with a Salafi-Wahhabi orientation—have opposed Al Saud rule and rejected both the legitimacy of its political order and attempts to justify its rule through these concepts.
Conclusion
Traditional sources of legitimacy in Saudi Arabia have retained their importance and continue to perform a significant legitimizing function. Reinterpreting traditional concepts while simultaneously drawing on modern sources of legitimacy—including the expansion and strengthening of citizenship rights among different segments of Saudi society—could help prevent a future legitimacy crisis in the country. However, traditional interpretations of concepts such as the guardian (walī al-amr), together with the tensions between the actions of the Saudi regime under the banner of its development programs and traditional understandings of religion, the functions of Islamic governance, and Saudi Arabia’s status as Umm al-Qurā (or the core of nation of the Islamic world) may pose significant challenges. These tensions are likely to intensify competing interpretations of religious concepts and ideas within Saudi society.

Keywords

Subjects

- Aalishahi, Abdul Reza; Khorramshad, Mohammad Baqer; Barzegar, Ebrahim & Abbas Ali Rahbar, (2023 CE / 1402 AH), “Mohammad bin Salman and the Transition from Pan-Wahhabism to a Secular System”, Biannual Scientific Journal of Political Knowledge, Vol. 37, No. 1, pp. 189-212. [In Persian]
- Abdullah Khani, Ali, (2017), Security Theories, Tehran: Abrar Moaser. [In Persian]
- Abulhamid, Abdolhamid, (1974), The Foundations of Politics, Tehran: Tous. [In Persian]
- Aghabakhshi, Ali & Afshari Rad, Minoo, (2004), Dictionary of Political Sciences, Tehran: Chapar. [In Persian]
- Akbar, Ali, (1991), A Survey of Contemporary Political Thought, Tehran: Alast. [In Persian]
- Asadi, Ali Akbar, (2020), “The Gap between Tradition and Modernism and Political Stability in Saudi Arabia”, Contemporary Political Essays, Vol. 11, No. 3, pp. 1-26. [In Persian]
- Barzegar, Ebrahim; Khorramshad, Mohammad Baqer; Rahbar, Abbas Ali & Abdul Reza Aalishahi, (2020), “Dysfunctions of Wahhabism and the Deepening Rift between Bin Salman and Wahhabism”, International Relations Research Quarterly, Vol. 10, No. 39, pp. 177-204. [In Persian]
- Chegini, Rasul; Chegini, Mohammad Mehdi; Mir Ali, Mohammad Mehdi & Fatemeh Shokri, (2023), “Typology of Excommunication Factors in the Works of Sunni and Wahhabi Scholars Based on Theological and Jurisprudential Origins”, Theological Research Journal, Vol. 10, No. 19, pp. 271-298. [In Persian]
- Dekmejian, Hrair, (1998), “The Role of the Consultative Council in the Saudi Arabian Power Structure”, Translated by Hamid Ahmadi, Middle East Studies Quarterly, Vol. 5, No. 4, pp. 135-156. [In Persian]
- Hashemi, Seyed Mohammad Ali, (2021), Contemporary Jurisprudential Thought and Women's Political Participation, Tehran: Negah-e Moaser. [In Persian]
- Joufar, Mohammad Reza; Mehrabi, Alireza & Hamid Reza Mohammadi, (2024), “Pathology of the Relationship between Religion and State in Saudi Arabia with Emphasis on the Theoretical Framework of Jean Gottmann”, Geography Journal, Vol. 22, No. 8, pp. 175-195. [In Persian]
- Machiavelli, Niccolo, (2010), The Prince, Translated by Mahmoud Mahmoud, Tehran: Negah-e Aval. [In Persian]
- Majidi, Hassan & Mehdi Taheri, (2022), “Analysis of the Indicators of Islamist Identity Politics in Saudi Arabia”, Studies in World Islamic Politics, Vol. 11, No. 1, pp. 43-69. [In Persian]
- Mohtaq, Ali, (2000), Documents of Iran-Saudi Arabia Relations (1978-1925), Tehran: Publications of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. [In Persian]
- Qorbani, Fahimeh; Ahmadi, Hamid & Mehdi Zakerian, (2022 ), “The Impact of the Legitimacy Crisis on the Domestic and Regional Policies of Saudi Arabia (The Era of King Salman)”, Middle East Quarterly, Year 29, No. 3, p. 109. [In Persian]
- Sardarnia, Khalilollah & Saeed Mohseni, (2019), “Analyzing the Political Legitimacy of the Saudi Government in the Context of the Arab Spring and Vision 2030”, the Majlis and Rahbord (Parliament and Strategy) Quarterly Journal, Vol. 26, No. 99, pp. 331-356. [In Persian]
- Vincent, Andrew, (1992), Theories of the State, Translated by Hossein Bashiriyeh, Tehran: Nashr-e Ney. [In Persian]
- Weber, Max, (1995), Economy and Society, Translated by Abbas Manouchehri et al., Tehran: Moli. [In Persian]
In Arabic
- A Group of Authors, (1999), The Simplified Encyclopedia of Contemporary Religions, Sects and Parties, Supervised by: Mani' bin Hammad al-Juhani, Riyadh: Dar al-Nadwah al-'Alamiyyah for Printing, Publishing and Distribution. [In Arabic]
- Abu 'Aliyah, Abdul Fattah Husain, (1991), Lectures on the History of the First Saudi State, Riyadh: Dar al-Marikh. [In Arabic]
- Abu Hakima, Ahmad Mustafa, (n.d.), The Book of the Meteor's Glimmer in the Biography of Muhammad bin Abd al-Wahhab, n.p. [In Arabic]
- Abu Ya'la, Muhammad Husayn bin al-Farra', (1983), The Ordinances of Government, Qom: Islamic Propagation Office. [In Arabic]
- Al al-Shaykh, Abdul Latif bin Abdul Rahman, (1992), A Collection of Najdi Treatises and Questions by Some of the Eminent Scholars of Najd, Riyadh: Dar al-'Asimah. [In Arabic]
- Al-'Aql, Nasser bin Abdul Karim, (2004), Islamism, Not Wahhabism, Riyadh: Dar al-Kunuz Ishbiliya. [In Arabic]
- Al-Fath, 'Arif, (2009), A Summary of the History of Basra and Al-Ahsa, Beirut: The Arab House for Encyclopedias. [In Arabic]
- Al-Fawzan, Salih bin Fawzan bin Abdullah, (2010), Explanation of the Creed of the Reviver Imam Muhammad bin Abd al-Wahhab, Riyadh: Maktabat Dar al-Minhaj. [In Arabic]
- Al-Jabri, Muhammad Abed, (2004), Religion, State, and the Application of Shari'ah, Beirut: Center for Arab Unity Studies. [In Arabic]
- Al-Maqdisi, Abu Muhammad 'Asim, (n.d.), The Clear Revelations on the Disbelief of the Saudi State, n.p. [In Arabic]
- Al-Mas'ari, Muhammad bin Abdullah, (2002), Muḥasabat al-Hukkam, London: Committee for the Defence of Legitimate Rights. [In Arabic]
- Al-Mas'ari, Muhammad bin Abdullah, (2002), Obedience to the Rulers: Its Limits and Constraints, London: Committee for the Defence of Legitimate Rights. [In Arabic]
- Al-Mas'ari, Muhammad bin Abdullah, (2002), The Illegitimacy of the Saudi State, London: Committee for the Defence of Legitimate Rights. [In Arabic]
- Al-Mawardi, Ali bin Muhammad, (1966), The Ordinances of Government and Religious Governorships, Cairo: Maktabah and Matba'ah Mustafa al-Babi al-Halabi. [In Arabic]
- Al-Nizam al-Asasi lil-Hukm [The Basic Law of Governance (Saudi Arabia)].
https://hrlibrary.umn.edu/arabic/Saudi_Con.html [In Arabic]
- Al-Qattan, Ahmad & Muhammad Tahir al-Zayn, (n.d.), The Imam of Tawhid; Shaykh Muhammad bin Abd al-Wahhab: The Call and the State, Alexandria: Dar al-Iman. [In Arabic]
- Al-'Uthaymin, Muhammad bin Salih bin Muhammad, (2000), Liqa' al-Bab al-Maftuh [The Open Door Session], Sessions Held by the Sheikh at his Home Every Thursday, Began in Late Shawwal 1412 AH and Ended on Thursday 14 Safar 1421 AH, Audio Lessons Transcribed by the Islamweb Network Website, The Part Number is the Session Number. [In Arabic]
- Faraj, 'Atiyyah Ismail, (2007), The Political Thought of Imam Ibn Taymiyyah, Amman: Dar al-Faruq. [In Arabic]
- Ibn Abd al-Wahhab, Muhammad bin Abd al-Wahhab bin Sulaiman, (2010), A Collection of Treatises on Tawhid and Faith, Part One, The Twelfth Treatise: Sunnah Usul 'Adhimah Mufidah [A Beneficial Sunnah of Great Principles], Riyadh: Imam Muhammad bin Saud University. [In Arabic]
- Ibn Baz, Abdul Aziz bin Abdullah, (n.d.), A Collection of Various Fatwas and Articles, Compiled and Arranged by: Muhammad bin Sa'd Al-Shuway'ir, Prepared and Formatted by: The Ibn Baz Website, “Statement on the Rights of the Rulers over the Ummah”. [In Arabic]
- Ibn Bishr al-Najdi al-Hanbali, Uthman bin Abdullah, (1982), The Mark of Glory in the History of Najd, Riyadh: Publications of Dar al-Malik Abdulaziz. [In Arabic]
- Ibn Rais bin al-Rais, Abdulaziz, (n.d.), Dispelling the Stubborn Revealing Factors in His Declaration of Takfir against the State of Tawhid, n.p. [In Arabic]
- Ibn Taymiyyah, Abu al-'Abbas Taqi al-Din Ahmad bin Abdul Halim, (1986), The Methodology of the Prophetic Sunnah in Refuting the Speech of the Qadari Shi'ah, Cairo: Maktabat Ibn Taymiyyah. [In Arabic]
- Ibn Taymiyyah, Abu al-'Abbas Taqi al-Din Ahmad bin Abdul Halim, (2004), The Collected Fatwas of Ibn Taymiyyah, Al-Madinah Al-Munawwarah: The King Fahd Complex for the Printing of the Holy Qur'an. [In Arabic]
- Ibn Taymiyyah, Ahmad bin Abdul Halim, (1997), The Shari'ah-based Governance in Reforming the Ruler and the Ruled, Riyadh: Ministry of Islamic Affairs, Endowments, Da'wah and Guidance - Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. [In Arabic]
- Kashishian, Joseph, (2003), The Caliphate in Saudi Arabia, Translated by Ghada Haidar, Beirut: Dar al-Saqi. [In Arabic]
- Salman bin Abdulaziz, (2011), “The Historical and Intellectual Foundations of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia”, 'Ayn al-Yaqin: An Arab Political Weekly Magazine, March 30, Wednesday, Issue 11810. [In Arabic]
- Shamiyah, Jibran, (1986), Al Sa'ud: Their Past and Their Future, London: Riad El-Rayyes & Mosharekoh Al-Mahdouda. [In Arabic]
- Tabatabai, Seyed Mohammad Hossein, (1996), Al-Mizan in Interpreting the Qur'an, Qom: Islamic Publications Office. [In Arabic]
- Tantawi, Seyed Muhammad, (n.d.), The Moderate Interpretation of the Noble Qur'an, Software Version: Jami' al-Tafasir. [In Arabic]