Process Mining of Anti-meritocracy in the Public Sector: A Grounded Theory Approach

Yari, Mohammad; Ziaaddini, Mohammad; Hadavinejad, Mostafa; Ebrahiminejad, Mehdi

doi:10.22054/qpss.2023.70554.3124

Process Mining of Anti-meritocracy in the Public Sector: A Grounded Theory Approach

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Mohammad Yari ¹

Mohammad Ziaaddini ²

Mostafa Hadavinejad ³

Mehdi Ebrahiminejad ⁴

¹ Ph.D Student, Department of Management, Rafsanjan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Rafsanjan, Iran

² Assistant Professor, Department of Management, Rafsanjan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Rafsanjan, Iran

³ Associate Professor, Department of Management, Vali -e- Asr University of Rafsanjan, Rafsanjan, Iran

⁴ Professor, Department of Management and Economic, Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman, Kerman

https://doi.org/10.22054/qpss.2023.70554.3124

Abstract

Introduction
This study aimed to use process mining to address the issue of anti-meritocracy in the public sector and develop a conceptual model that highlights the importance of utilizing the skills and talents of the elite. The study began by conducting interviews with 17 experts in the field, which led to the identification of 302 initial themes through open coding. From these themes, 16 categories were extracted and grouped into causal conditions (including individual components like Machiavellianism, group components like unhealthy competition, and organizational components such as the possibility of power shifts within the organization), strategies (such as excluding the elite from the public sphere), background conditions (including personal attributes like narcissism and behavioral traits like unhealthy competition), and intervening conditions (such as inappropriate organizational structures). The central category identified was the tendency towards anti-meritocracy, with consequences including the non-acceptance of elite forces. The research findings highlight the importance of utilizing the expertise of the elite in decision-making processes, as failure to do so can hinder the public sector’s strengths and turn opportunities into threats.
Statement of the problem
The increasing importance of human resource initiatives and the recognition of the value of elite individuals have led many organizations to seek effective solutions by employing their talents. This trend has been particularly evident in elite development organizations within the government sector. The significance of employee talent and the pursuit of enhancing their knowledge and skills have become a global issue, with organizations striving to promote a culture of organizational talent management within their communities (Guth et al., 2012). Managing elite human resources effectively is crucial for improving organizational performance, as recognizing and leveraging their latent talents is a prerequisite for growth and prosperity. This is especially important for managers and leaders of government organizations, which are subject to greater scientific scrutiny due to their dynamic nature. As the public sector becomes more complex, capable leaders are increasingly in demand (Sejeli & Abu Mansor, 2015). In this line, the present study aimed to address the primary question of what the process of anti-meritocracy in the public sector entails. Sub-questions explored various aspects of anti-meritocracy, including its main categories, causal conditions, background conditions, intervening conditions, strategies of action and interaction, and consequences. The primary purpose of this research was to conduct a process mining analysis of anti-meritocracy in the public sector. Specific objectives included identifying the main categories of anti-meritocracy in the public sector, investigating its causal, background, and intervening conditions, examining strategies of action and interaction, and comprehending its consequences.
Method
The study used grounded theory as the research strategy. This systematic and qualitative approach is used to create a comprehensive theory that explains a wide-scale process, action, or interaction concerning a given topic. Therefore, grounded theory was deemed a suitable approach to investigate the process of anti-meritocracy in the public sector.
Suggestions
Public sector human resources departments should develop and implement elite recruitment strategies based on internal and external environmental factors. Research results should be communicated to organizational leaders to keep them informed of the status of elite recruitment and enable them to maintain and improve their strengths, reduce weaknesses, take advantage of opportunities, and minimize losses caused by threats. The dimensions and components of the evaluation of the public sector environment to attract the elite should be communicated to organizations to monitor their situation at specific times.
Comprehensive programs should be formulated to create active and dynamic environments for human resources, providing the ground for the development of creativity and innovation for the elite in order to retain them. Intellectual property laws should be adopted and regulations should be approved to increase the motivation of elite individuals and prevent them from leaving the public sector. Protecting the rights of intellectual property is considered one of the inalienable rights of the elite and effective laws that can help motivate them. Using the meritocracy and succession can help to utilize the abilities and talents of the elite, avoid politicization, and prevent them from leaving the public sector. This can also increase their motivation to serve in the public sector.
The experts suggested several ways to combat anti-meritocracy in the public sector. One approach is to create more opportunities for talented individuals and ensure that rules and regulations are properly implemented. Additionally, establishing a performance evaluation system with executive guarantees can help promote a merit-based culture. It is also important to rely on individuals who are part of the elite group, believe in the value of meritocracy, and are willing to trust the elite to address the country’s challenges. To further promote meritocracy, it is crucial to train individuals committed to eliminating anti-meritocracy. This can involve avoiding appointing individuals who are jealous, as the elite typically have high occupational expectations.

Keywords

Elites

Anti-meritocracy

Public Sector

Grounded Theory

Subjects

Public policy

Alizadeh Fahima, Hadovinejad Mostafa, (2019), “Analyzing the Anti-elitism Process in the Organization Based on the Interpretive Mapping Scheme of the Data Base Theory”, Organizational Resource Management Research, 9 (1):165-183. [In Persian].

- Bashiriya Hossein, (2007), Obstacles to Political Development in Iran, Tehran: Gam No. [In Persian]

- Bealey, F, (1996), “Democratic Elitism and the Autonomy of Elites”, International Political Science Review, 17(3): 319-331.

- Butamore, T. B, (2010), Elites and Society, Translated by Ali Reza Tayeb, Tehran: University of Tehran. [In Persian]

- Corbin, J. and Strauss, A, (1990), “Grounded Theory Research: Procedures, Canons, and Evaluative Criteria”, Qualitative Sociology, Vol. 13, No. 2, pp. 3-21. [In Persian]

- Danai Fard, H., and Elwani, S. M. (2007), “Metaphorical Reasoning Strategy in Theorizing: The Formation of the Theory of Transfer of Public Managers”, Quarterly Letter of the Teacher of Humanities, 3(11), 107-135. [In Persian]

- Darabi, Ali2010), Political Currentism in Iran, Tehran: Farhang and Andisheh Research Institute. [In Persian]

- Estlund, D, (2003)‚ “Why not Epistocracy?”, In: N. Reshotko (Ed.), Desire, Identity and Existence: Essays in Honor of T. M. Penner, Kelowna, BC: Academic Printing & Publishing, pp. 53-69.

- Javadani, Hamid, (2005), “Investigation of Internal Factors that Strengthen the Process of the Departure of Scientific Elites from the Country”, Management and Development Process, No. 4, 36-47. [In Persian]

- Karatop, B. Kubat, C. & Uygun, Ö, (2015), “Talent Management in Manufacturing System Using Fuzzy Logic Approach”, Computers & Industrial Engineering, 86: 127-136.

- Khosravi, Ahmad Ali, Khosravi, Saeed, Mansouri Bidkani Mehdi & Mir Sultan, Ali, (2019), “Elite Migration and Its Relationship with Development: Opportunities and Challenges for Policymakers”, Bimonthly Scientific-Research Education Strategies in Medical Sciences, 12 (6): 8-18. [In Persian]

- Koslowski, P, (2010), Elements of a Philosophy of Management and Organization, UK: Springer.

- Malikian Bahabadi, Mohsin; Mohseni Zanoozi, Hashim & Keshavarz, Mohsen, (2012), “Perfectionism and Self-esteem in Academic and Sports Elites and Non-elite People in Tehran”, Knowledge and Research in Applied Psychology, Fall, Volume. 11, Number. 41, 119 -137. [In Persian]

- Michaels, E., Handfield-Jones, H. and Axelrod, B, (2001), The War for Talent, Boston: Harvard Business School Press.

- Moghimi Zahra, Memarzadeh Tehran Gholamreza, Albarzi Mahmood, (2018), “Ethical Management of Recruiting Elites in Iran's Government Organizations”, Ethics in Science and Technology, 14 (5): 204-208. [In Persian]

- Moin, Mohammad, (2004), Farhang Farsi, Amir Kabir, 8th Edition, Tehran, Volume. 1. [In Persian]

- Momayezi, Mahdiye; Mazloumi, Seyed Saeed, Aminipour, Mohammadreza and Mamizi, Mohammad, (2015), “Educational Problems of Brilliant Students of Shahid Sadougi University of Medical Sciences in Yazd in 2012”, Iranian Journal of Education in Medical Sciences, 12(1), 55-66. [In Persian]

- Mousavirad, Seyed Hamid, Qudsian, Hossein, (2014), “Analyzing Elite Migration and the Impact of Deterrence Policies Using System Dynamics”, Strategic Management Scientific Quarterly, 21(59), 37-62. [In Persian]

- Muthanna, A, (2015), “Quality Education Improvement: Yemen and the Problem of the Brain Drain”, Policy Futures in Education, Vol. 13, No. 1: 141-148.

- Refahi, Jhaleh, (2001), “Investigation of Some Characteristics of Gifted Students in Shiraz Schools, Summary of Articles of the First National Conference on Gifted Talents”, 47.

- Rezaian, A., & Soltani, F, (2009), “Introducing a Comprehensive and Systematic Model of Talent Management to Improve the Individual Performance of Oil Industry Employees”, Management and Human Resources in the Oil Industry, 1(3), 750.

- Rouhani, Ali, Khazuri, Saeed, Anbarlou, Masoud, (2019), “Presenting a Background Theory of the Confrontation of Young Elites with the Bureaucracy of the National Elite Foundation”, Social Studies and Research in Iran, 8(4), 745-772. [In Persian]

- Sadeghi, Abbas & Nader Efghi, (2005), “The Role of Universities in Reducing Elite Migration”, Lafat, No. 36, 25. [In Persian]

- Shahabadi, Abolfazl & Karim Qallu, Mohammad Hossein & Mahmoudi, Abdullah, (2012), “Investigating Factors Affecting Brain Drain,” (Case Study: Iran), Business Journal, (39), 39-81. [In Persian]

- Shakrinia, Iraj, (2009), “The Relationship between Religious Identity, Religious Attitude and Psychological Toughness with Mental Health in the Basiji Elites”, Journal of Humanities of Imam Hossein University (AS), Islamic Education and Training, 23 70: 78(97). [In Persian]

- Stooky، S, (2008), “The Future of Critical Management Studies: Populism and Elitism”, Organization, 15(6): 922–924.

- Strauss, Anselm & Juliet Corbin, (2010), Fundamentals of Qualitative Research; Techniques and Stages of Production of Contextual Theory, Translated by Ebrahim Afshar, Tehran: Ney Publishing. [In Persian]

- Talebzadeh Shoushtari, Leila, Khademi Ashkazari, Moluk, (2018), “Optimum Management of Elite Human Resources by Examining Needs, Obstacles and Problems and Proposed Solutions from their Own Point of View”, Human Resource Management Research, 10(3), 215-237. [In Persian]

- Tremmel J.، Wilhelm J, (2015), “Democracy or Epistocracy? Age as a Criterion of Voter Eligibility”, In: Tremmel J, Mason, A., Godli, P. H. Dimitrijoski, I, (Eds), Youth Quotas and Other Efficient Forms of Youth Participation in Ageing Societies, Heidelberg, pp. 125–48.

- Tribal, Causal, (2009), Investigating the Reasons for the Departure of Specialized Forces from the Country and Ways to Reduce It. Expert Manpower Needs Assessment Plan and Human Resources Development Policy of the Country, Tehran: Higher Education Research and Planning Institute. [In Persian]

- Wright, P. M. & Snell, S. A, (1998), “Toward a Unifying Framework for Exploring Fit and Flexibility in Strategic Human Resource Management”, Academy of Management Review, 23(4): 756-772.
- Afrooz, Gholamali, (1986), “Smart and Creative Students”, Peyvand Magazine, 88: 299-287. [In Persian]
- Arasteh, Hamidreza & Mahmoudi Rad, Maryam, (2002), “Identification, Characteristics and Growth of Elites”, Rahiyaft, 30, 5-12. [In Persian]
- Bottomore, T, (2006), Elites and Society (2nd Edition), London: Rutledge.
- Byham W. C., Smith A. B., Paese M. J, (2002), “Grow Your Own Leaders: How to Identify, Develop and Retain Leadership Talent”, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Financial Times/Prentice Hall.
- Etzioni-Halevy, E, (1990)‚ “Democratic-elite Theory: Stabilization Versus Breakdown of Democracy”, European Journal of Sociology, 31(2): 317-350.
- Fartukzadeh, Hamidreza & Hasan Eshraghi, (2008), “Dynamic Modeling of the Phenomenon of Elite Migration and the Role of the Higher Education System in It”, Higher Education Research and Planning Quarterly, No. 5, 139-168. [In Persian]
- Hossam Ghazi, Rozhan, (2015), “Pathology of Populist Justice Discourse and Its Reflection in Iran's Political Culture”, Political Studies Quarterly, 7, Number 28,133-150. [In Persian]
- Hosseini Ahmadi, Seyed Mohammad Reza, Golshani, Ali Reza, Shafiei, Ismail, (2019), “Regional-geographic Pathology of the Role of Iranian Elites in Decision-making from the Perspective of Public Policy”, Geography Quarterly (Regional Planning), 9(3), 405-427. [In Persian]
- Hosseini, Seyedhasan, (2010), “The Latest Statistics of Elites Leaving the Country”, http://khabarfarsi.com/ext/6698796. [In Persian]
- Karatop, , Kubat, C. and Uygun, Ö, (2015), “Talent Management in Manufacturing System Using Fuzzy Logic Approach”, Computers & Industrial Engineering, 86: 127-136.
- Michaels, E; Handfield-Jones, H. & Axelrod, B, (2001), The War for Talent, Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
- Min J. B, (2015), “Epistocracy and Democratic Epistemology”, Politics in Central Europe, 11: 91-112.
- Mosca, G, (1935), The Ruling Class, Translated by. A. Living Stone, New York: Mac Graw Hill.
- Odhiambo, G. O, (2013), “Academic Brain Drain: Impact and Implications for Public Higher Education Quality in Kenya”, Research in Comparative and International Education, Vol. 8, No. 4: 510-523.
- Pareto, V, (1935), “The Mind and Society”, (Vol. 1), Рипол Классик.
- Polk, Jonathan & Rovny, Jan & Bakker, Ryan & Edwards, Erica, (2017), “Explaining the Salience of Anti-elitism and Reducing Political Corruption for Political Parties in Europe with the 2014 Chapel Hill Expert Survey Data”, Research and Politics, January-March 2017: 1–9, sagepub. com/home/rap.
- Rothwell W. J, (2011), “Replacement Planning: A Starting Point for Succession Planning and Talent Management”, International Journal of Training and Development, 15: 87-99.
- Sejeli، S. & Abu Mansor. N, (2005), “Leadership Derailment: Does Self-leadership Matters?,” International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 5 (Special Issue), 22-26.
- Wells, Chris & Lewis A & Friedland, T, (2021), “News Media Use, Talk Networks, and Anti-Elitism across Geographic Location”, Evidence from Wisconsin https://doi.org/10.1.