Analyzing the Intertwined Crises of Hassan Rouhani’s Government (2013–2020) and their Consequences for Political Participation

Shabafrooz, Nima; Morshedizad, Ali; Nozari, Hoseenali; Ahmadi, Hamid

doi:10.22054/qpss.2022.64688.2952

Analyzing the Intertwined Crises of Hassan Rouhani’s Government (2013–2020) and their Consequences for Political Participation

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Nima Shabafrooz ¹

Ali Morshedizad ²

Hoseenali Nozari ³

Hamid Ahmadi ⁴

¹ Ph.D Student, Islamic Azad University Central Tehran Branch, Tehran, Iran

² Associate Professor, Political Sciences, Shahed University, Tehran, Iran

³ Assistant Professor, Political Sciences, Islamic Azad University Karaj Branch, Tehran, Iran

⁴ Professor, Political Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22054/qpss.2022.64688.2952

Abstract

Introduction
Both in pre- and in post-Revolution periods, Iran’s critical geopolitical and geostrategic position, as well as its revolutionary Islamic ideology, has made it a highly important player at both the regional and international levels. This sensitive and perilous position has exposed the country to various incidents and events, including economic sanctions, recreation and overt and covert support of terrorist groups, and the sale of advanced weapons to regional actors. The resulting scenarios and potential power vacuums could create a divide in political participation and society, leading to a legitimacy gap, questions of authority, and a disruption of national unity. Given the importance of the current moment and the conditions ahead, it is essential for scholarly community to analyze and provide solutions for potential crises related to political participation. Furthermore, numerous domestic and structural obstacles have emerged as significant challenges to political participation in the Islamic Republic of Iran over the past four decades, leading to a crisis and serious problems in political participation.
The crisis of political participation is a clear indication of an ineffective political system. This crisis stems from a growing gap between the people and the governance system, eroding trust between political leaders and people and causing a rift between the state and the nation. This lack of trust in political leaders impedes people’s willingness to participate in the political process, resulting in political deadlocks and potentially dire consequences for society.
The Purpose of Research
The purpose of this research was to examine the interrelated effects of multiple crises, including inefficiency, distribution, identity, influence, and legitimacy crises, on the political system, with a particular focus on the presidency of Hassan Rouhani. The research question is, what are the consequences of crises for active political participation?
Methodology
This research employed a descriptive–analytical method, utilizing a cross-sectional study of a particular time period.

Findings
By exploring the correlations and conflicts between data, the study confirms that any political crisis signals a decrease in authority and legitimacy, ultimately resulting in a decline in active political participation and a crisis in the political system. The events of December 2017, the rise in price of gasoline and the unrest of November 2019, the Ukrainian plane crash, the crisis of inefficiency in price control, broken promises, and the distribution crisis led to a growing class divide and the decline of the urban middle class. Moreover, the gap between the language used by the governance system and the language of the people, the people’s demands and how they interacted with the political system, and the quality of their influence on politics can only be evaluated by criteria such as political participation. It is important to note that various events and occurrences, influenced by political actors and competing, parallel forces both inside and outside the government’s decision-making, have contributed to the widening scope of the crisis. However, for the purposes of this study, the term crisis refers specifically to the period of Rouhani’s administration.
Discussion and Conclusion
The analysis revealed that the inefficiency crisis and distribution crisis, along with more institutionalized crises of identity and influence, erodes legitimacy at different levels, thereby reducing political participation. This study aimed to demonstrate the relationship between crises and political participation, highlighting how the inefficiency of Rouhani’s government and its inability to distribute economic and political resources fairly led to a decline in legitimacy, increased dissatisfaction, and a drop in political participation. Specifically, four major failures of the 11th and 12th governments were identified, namely, foreign policy failures, mismanagement of the Ministry of Science, failure to control the monetary and financial crisis in various markets, and failure to manage COVID–19 pandemic.

Keywords

Identity Crisis

Inefficiency Crisis

Distribution Crisis

Influence Crisis

Legitimacy Crisis

Political Participation Crisis

Subjects

Iranian Domestic Policy

References

- Abdullah, Sharif M, (1999), The Age of Cloud Crisis and Individual Power, A Discourse on Genuine Leadership in a Turbulent World, Translated by Bijan Mohammad, Volume. 1, First Edition, Tehran: Ahavan Publications. [In Persian]

- Amid, Hassan, (2011), Farhang Amid, Volume One, Thirty-Eighth Edition, Tehran: Amirkabir Publishing.

- Amirkabiri, Alireza, (1997), “Crisis Management”, Tadbir Magazine, Azar, Vol. 1, No. 78.

- Bashirieh, Hossein, (2007), Reason in Politics: Thirty-Five Discourses in Philosophy, Sociology and Political Development, Volume One, Third Edition, Tehran: Negah Moaser Publications.

- Bashirieh, Hossein, (2008), Transition to Democracy, Contemporary View, Volume One, Third Edition, Tehran: Contemporary View Publications.

- Bashirieh, Hossein, (2019), From Here to Nowhere, An Introduction to Political Pathology, Vol. 1, First Edition, Tehran: Ney Publishing.

- Bercher, Michael, (2003), Crisis in World Politics, Translated by Heidar Ali Baluchi, Volume One, First Edition, Tehran: Research Institute for Strategic Studies.

- Binder, Leonard James, Coleman, Joseph La Palombara, Lucian W.pye, Sidney Verba,and Myron Weiner, (1971), Crises and Sequences in Political Development, Princeton & New Jersey: Princeton University Press.

- Fars News Agency, “Four Big Failures of Rouhani's Government”, Khaje Sarvi, Gholamreza, 03/06/2021, website address https://www.farsnews.ir. [In Persian]

- Fars News Agency, “What is the Role of the Rouhani Government in the Level of People's Participation in the Presidential Elections?”, 13/06/2021, website address https://www.farsnews.ir. [In Persian]

- Ghavam, Abdolali, (2000), Challenges and Political Development, Volume One, Seventh Edition, Tehran: Qoms Publications

- Giddens, Anthony, Satin, Philip, (2016), Sociology, Translated by Houshang Naebi, Vol. 2, Seventeenth Edition, Tehran: Publishing.

- Habermas, Jürgen, (2001), The Crisis of Legitimacy, The Theory of the Modern Capitalist State, Translated by Jahangir Moeini, Volume One, First Edition, Tehran: Gam No Publications.

- Hajiani, Ibrahim & at al., (2015), Protests and Unrest in January 2017; Analyzes and Estimates by Ebrahim Hajiani, Vol. 1, First Edition, Tehran: Research Institute for Strategic Studies.

- Held, David, (2018), Models of Democracy, Translated by Abbas Mokhber, Vol. 1, Chach IV, Tehran: Intellectuals Publications and Women's Studies.

- Holab, Robert, Habermas, Jürgen, (2014), Critique in the Public Sphere, Translated by Hossein Bashirieh, Vol. 1, Eighth Edition, Tehran: Ney Publishing.

- Kashi, Gholamreza, (2006), The Evolution and Order of Democracy in Iran, Vol. 1, First Edition, Tehran: Ney Publishing.

- Kazemi, Seyed Ali Asghar, (2006), Political Management and Government Policy, Volume One, Fifth Edition, Tehran, Farhang-e-Islami Publications.

- Lucian W.pye, (1971), “Identity and Political Culture”, In: Leonard Binder, James. Coleman, Joseph Lapalombara, Lucian W.pye, Sidny Verba, and Mayron Weiner, Crises Sequencesin Political Development, Princeton & New Jersy: Princeton University.

- Lucien Pai, et al., (2001), Crises and Sequences in Political Development, Translated by Gholamreza Khajeh Sarvi, Volume 1, First Edition, Tehran: Institute for Strategic Studies Publications.

Micheal, Brown, (1996), The Intenational Dimensions of Internal Conflict, Cambridget Massachusetts & London, The Mitpress Paperback, 671 PP. Publidhed: 17

- Nowruzpour, Morteza, (2019), “Analysis of Political Protests”, Journal of Political Science, Autumn, Vol. 14, No. 4.

- Pai, W., Lucien, et al., (2001), Crisis and Sequence in Political Development, Translated by Gholamreza Khajeh Sarvi, Volume 1, First Edition, Tehran: Publication of Strategic Studies.

- Razavi, Seyed Mohammad, (2019), Andisheh Salar Sepehr Siyasat, by Abolfazl Delavari, Vol. 1, First Edition, Tehran: House of Political Science Thinkers Publications.

- Radar Economy News Agency, 43% Drop in Stock Market Returns and Funds that Went out of People's Pockets!, 25/05/2021 website address https://www.radareghtesad.ir. [In Persian]

- Sadeghi, Fatemeh, at el., (1398), Social Gaps in Iran, Volume One, First Edition, Tehran: Publisher of Culture Research Institute, Art and Communication Publications.

- Saveh Doroudi, Mostafa, (2016), Organizational Strategies and Crisis Management, Vol. 1, Second Edition, Tehran: Farabi College Publishing.

- Seifzadeh, Hossein, (2009), Modernization of Development and Political Transformation, Vol. 1, First Edition, Tehran: Qoms Publishing

- Sheikhzadeh Joshani, Sedigheh, (1398), “Analysis of the Mechanisms of Resolving the IRGC Disputes with a View to Iran”, Journal of Political Science, Summer, Vol. 14, No. 3.

- Student News Agency, “What is the Role of the Rouhani Government in the Level of Ppeople's Participation in the Presidential Elections?”, 13/06/2021, website address https://snn.ir/. [In Persian]

- Tadgar, Robert, (2009), Because Humans Rebel, Translated by Ali Morshedizad, Vol. 1, Third Edition, Tehran: Institute for Strategic Studies.

- Tajik, Mohammad Reza, (2000), Crisis Management, Volume One, First Edition, Tehran: Goftman Publishing.