A Comparative Analysis of Fundamental Religious Beliefs of Taliban and Salafism: Some Solutions for Iran’s Foreign Policy

Sorkhi Khozani, Saeed; Abedi Renani, Ali; Karbalaie Pazouki, Ali

doi:10.22054/qpss.2023.73455.3232

A Comparative Analysis of Fundamental Religious Beliefs of Taliban and Salafism: Some Solutions for Iran’s Foreign Policy

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Saeed Sorkhi khozani ¹

Ali Abedi Renani ²

Ali Karbalaie Pazouki ³

¹ Ph.D Student, Department of Islamic Philosophy and Theology, University of Ilam, Ilam, Iran

² Assistant Professor, Political Science, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran

³ Associate Professor, Department of Islamic Philosophy and Theology, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22054/qpss.2023.73455.3232

Abstract

Introduction
Each Islamic denomination follows its respective beliefs to forge connections with other Islamic denominations and even non-Islamic religions. Religion plays a pivotal role in shaping their comprehension of Self, Other, and the approach towards communicating with others, ranging from acceptance to excommunication. In other words, religious beliefs constitute a foundation that governs the relations between different religions. A precise and nuanced understanding of diverse Islamic denominations is essential for avoiding the one-size-fits-all perspective that may see the diverse groups in the same way. Such an understanding paves the way for recognizing historical, religious, and social distinctions, facilitating more informed and effective approaches to interact with different religious groups.
The teachings of the Quran and the prophetic tradition prohibit sectarian conflicts, underscoring the unity and convergence among followers of different Islamic denominations. The empathy and convergence seem to be crucial, especially considering the constant efforts by the Western world to sow discord and division within Islamic countries. For example, the establishment of ISIS in the Middle East involved the Muslim nations, with the ultimate aim of ensuring security for Israel. Recently, the resurgence of the Taliban in Afghanistan has made it essential to reassess their foundational beliefs, laying the groundwork for fostering more symbiotic relations with them.
The Deoband school of thought is considered one of the influential Islamic denominations in the recent developments of the region. Deobandis adhere to the Hanafi school of Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh) and Maturidism as a school of Islamic theology. The Deobandi movement emerged with the purpose of opposing the British East India Company. Due to their concerted efforts, Deobandis rapidly spread across the Indian subcontinent, later establishing a significant base in Pakistan and Afghanistan and founding religious schools and educational centers there. The Taliban group is one the movements developed out of the adherence to the religious beliefs of the Deoband school of thought. Against this backdrop, the present research aimed to examine three key issues: the fundamental religious beliefs of the Taliban, the distinction between the Taliban and Salafism, and suggestions for Iran’s strategic foreign policy towards these groups with an eye to their religious beliefs.
Literature Review
Authored by Khalil Ahmad al-Saharanpuri, the book Al-Muhannad 'ala al-Mufannad [The Sword on the Disproved] not only provides responses to the inquiries posed by Wahhabi scholars but also elaborates on the beliefs of the scholars from Darul Uloom Deoband. The book unveils the conspiracies of adversaries and elucidates the true teachings of the venerable figures of Maturidism. The collection of essays titled Maghalat Al-Kawtheri [Kawtheri’s Essays] includes miscellaneous essays written by Muhammad Zahid al-Kawthari. The collection contains some essays that oppose the Wahhabi thought. While dismissing Wahhabism, al-Kawthari delves into the core beliefs of the Deobandi school of thought. In the article titled “Taliban and Deobandism” (2018), Mohammad Bagher Hassani examined the relationship between the Taliban and the Deobandi school. The author compared some Deobandi concepts with Wahhabism and other Sunni sects, highlighting their shared aspects as well as distinctions. Hassani’s descriptive–analytical research also focused on Islamic groups, such as the Taliban, which are recognized for their adherence to the theological doctrines of Maturidism.
In addition to comparative studies, there are also reference works on the theological beliefs of Maturidism and Wahhabism. A notable work is Kitab al-Tawhid [Book of Monotheism] by Abu Mansur al-maturidi, considered the canonical source for followers of the maturidi school of theology. Abu Mansur al-Maturidi refers to imitation in belief and faith as a wrong approach, focusing on the logical and narrative-based examination of the theological foundations of Maturidism. The book Minhaj al-Sunnah al-Nabawiyyah [The Path of Sunnah of the Prophet] was written by ibn Taymiyyah, a prominent Hanbali scholar considered as a founder and iconic figure of Salafism. The book deals with religious beliefs as well as several jurisprudential opinions and fatwas of Ibn Taymiyyah, including his unconventional views on refraining from visiting graves, and resorting to blessings and supplications. In addition, the article titled “Investigation of the Factors Affecting the Change in Iran’s Political–Defense Approach Towards the Taliban” (Parizad & Shahrestani, 2022) examined Iran’s foreign policy strategies concerning the Taliban group, highlighting the role of environmental factors and global structures.
Materials and Methods
The present study used the library method to collected and analyze the data.
Results and Discussion
According to the research results, the Taliban originated from Maturidi theology and Deobandi religious centers in Pakistan, and Salafism has its roots in the Wahhabi theology. Despite common origins, there are fundamental differences between the Taliban and

salafism, manifesting in salient theological and religious issues such as monotheism in worship, intercession, and the stance towards the shia. Notably, the Taliban, in contrast to Salafism, exhibits a broader, universalist approach to acceptance of and interactions with other groups, particularly the Shia. According to the religious teachings, unity and convergence are not merely tactical considerations but fundamental principles of the Islamic faith. Therefore, the foreign policy strategy of Islamic states should be aligned with religious teachings. The Islamic Republic of Iran, as an Islamic state, seems to have anchored its foreign policy on this principle. Considering geopolitical borders and ideological considerations, Iran has established positive relations with the Taliban group, showing tolerance in border conflicts and water disputes. Iran’s foreign policy towards the Taliban is characterized by Iran’s concern about the formation of Salafi and Wahhabi groups in Afghanistan. Therefore, given the doctrinal differences between these groups, Iran views the relations with the Taliban as appropriate to prevent the establishment of Salafi groups in its eastern neighbor. Moreover, Iran’s foreign policy can pursue cooperation and relations with the Taliban against a common adversary, namely the United States.
Conclusion
A comprehensive understanding of Islamic intellectual and religious schools is crucial to reach an accurate interpretation of the foundations of Islam. Knowledge about different schools of thought can offer a better understanding of religious teachings, facilitating a more accurate interpretation of religious doctrines and beliefs. Moreover, as indicated by the findings, such an understanding can aid in devising foreign policy strategies in dealing with diverse religious groups.

Keywords

Theological Foundations

Taliban

Salafism

Iran

Strategic Foreign Policy

Subjects

Developments in the Islamic world

In Persian
- Ebrahimi and Others, (2009), “Islam's Approach to International Relations Compared to Realist and Liberal Approaches”, Political Science Quarterly, Autumn and Winter, No. 12, pp. 42-5.
- Abu Zohra, Muhammad, (2004), History of Islamic Religions, First Edition, Qom: Religions Studies and Research Center.

- Ahmadipour, Zahra, (2018), “Explanation of Insecurity Factors in South-Eastern Iran”, Social Security Studies Quarterly, Fall, No. 27, pp. 13-44.

- Ardakani, Mohammad Abedi & Rastin Del, Najibullah, (2016), “Foreign Policy Strategies of the Islamic Republic of Iran in Establishing Convergence in the Middle East”, Political and International Approach Quarterly, Year 8, Spring, No. 3, pp. 146-175.

- Azmi, Hadi & Rangekesh, Mohammad Javad, (2013), “The Most Important Sources of Political-security Tension in Iran-Afghanistan Relations”, National Conference on Border Cities and Security, Spring, pp. 139-151.

- Eqtsad News, “Serdar Nilfroshan's Statements about Iran's Strategy against the Taliban”, 1400/07/20, https://b2n.ir/a28829.

- Isna, “Everyone Should Separate Their Accounts in the Region from America”, 1401/12/21, https://b2n.ir/h73648.

-ISNA, “5 Strategies of Iran in Relation to Afghanistan”, 9/6/1400, https://b2n.ir/y20655.

- Insaf News Base, “Taliban is one of the Genuine Movements of the Region”, 2019/9/12, https://b2n.ir/h47904.

- Shafqna News, “The Sidelines of the Taliban Delegation's Trip to Tehran:, 2021/2/2, https://b2n.ir/y84704.

- Perizad, Reza, (1400), “Investigation of the Factors Affecting the Change of Iran's political-defense Approach towards the Taliban Group”, Political Commentary Knowledge, Third Year, Autumn, No. 9, pp. 55-73.

-Johns, Anthony H, (2009), Islam and International Politics, Translated by: Reza Simir, First Edition, Tehran: Amkam Sadeq University Press.

- Jalali, Seyed Lotfollah, (2018), History and Beliefs of Matridiyeh, First Edition, Qom: Adian University Publications.

- Hosni, Muhammad Baqir, (1401), “Taliban and Deobandism”, Journal of Islamic Studies and Political Sciences, Spring and Summer, No. 1, pp. 132-152.

- Khamenei, Seyed Ali, (1347), Muslims in the Indian Movement, First Edition, Tehran: Asia Publications.

- Dehkordi et al., (1400), “Politicizing Foreign Relations of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the Middle East Region with an Emphasis on Syria”, Winter, No. 57, pp. 205-222.

- Khabar Online, “The Taliban Say They Are not Anti-Shia”, 1400/6/15, https://b2n.ir/q22398.

- Islamic Republic of Iran News Agency, “President's Conversation with the Minister of Foreign Affairs: America's Failure in Afghanistan Should be Turned into an Opportunity for Security and Peace”, 12/21/1401, https://b2n.ir/q85008.

- News Agency of the Islamic Republic of Iran, “Alam Network Interview with Kazemi Qomi”, 10/9/1401, https://b2n.ir/k70757.

- Tasnim News Agency, “Provincial Exclusive Conversation: Afghanistan is also Part of the Axis of Resistance”, 6/3/1400, https://b2n.ir/w68694.

- Tasnim News Report, “Jihad on Our Right is on the Threshold of Victory”, 3/15/1379, http://B2n.ir/e16630.

- Regional Office of Tasnim News Agency, “Meeting between the Leader and the Head of the New Jamor of Iran”, 6/6/1400, https://b2n.ir/r76042.

- Dehkordi and Others, (1400), “Politicizing Foreign Relations of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the Middle East Region with an Emphasis on Syria”, Islamic Revolution Approach Quarterly, Winter, No. 57, pp. 205-222.

- Radio Farda, “Molla Akhtar Mansour Was Negotiating in Iran”, 3/16/2015, https://b2n.ir/n95353.

- Rashid, Ahmed, (1377), Afghanistan, Taliban and Global Politics, First Edition, Translation: Abdul Ghafar Mohaghegh, Mashhad: Taneh.

- Rizvani, Ali Asghar, (1391), Wahhabism and Intercession, First Edition, Tehran: Mashaar.

- Rizvani, Ali Asghar, (1390), Wahhabism and the World of Barzakh, First Edition, Tehran: Mashaar.

- Rizvani, Ali Asghar, (2007), “Convergence of Islamic Religions from the Perspective of the Qur'an and Hadiths”, Tolo Noor Magazine, Spring, No. 25, pp. 103-124.

- Saharanpuri, Khalil Ahmad, (2014), Al-Mohand Ali Al-Mufand, First Edition, Translated by: Abdul Rahman Sarzabi, Mashhad: Javadan Publishing.

- Analytical Network of Elites, “Principle of Unity”, 2018/8/21, https://b2n.ir/p12533.

-Farmanian, Mehdi, (1402), “Namah Aftab”, Monthly Scientific and Analytical Journal of Shia Situationism, Summer, No. 1, pp. 28-36.

- Fath Elahi, Abdul Rahman, “Tehran's Relations with the Taliban are Inevitable”, Iranian Diplomacy, 1400/2/14, https://b2n.ir/q40847.

- Kazemi, Ali Asghar, (1370), Theories of Convergence in International Relations, First Edition, Tehran: Qoms.

- Kermani, Toba, (2012), “A Look at Wahhabism”, Articles and Reviews, Summer, Daftar 73, pp. 27-9.

- Karimi, Ali (1378), Political Management in Multicultural Societies, First Edition, Tehran: Islamic Council Research Center.

- Gohari Moghadam, Abuzar & Bashiri Lahaq, Maitham, (2016), “The Application of Convergence Theories in the Design of the Regional Convergence Model in the Neighborhood of the Islamic Republic of Iran”, Political Science Quarterly, Spring and Summer, No. 1, pp. 71-89.

- Valipour Zarumi, Hossein, (2008), “Mental and Psychological Obstacles to Convergence in the Middle East”, Strategy Quarterly, Winter, No. 26, pp. 360-344.

- Mojdeh, Vahid, (1400), Afghanistan and Five Years of Taliban Rule, First Edition, Tehran: Ney Publishing.
- Hashemi, Seyed Muhammad Ali (2018), Religion and Government in Saudi Arabia (the Identity and Structural link of Wahhabism with the Ruling Family of Saudi Arabia), First edition, Qom: Al-Mustafa International Translation and Publishing Center.
In Arabia

- Ibn Taymiyyah al-Bahrani & Abd al-Rahman ibn Muhammad, (1423 AH), Al-Ard Ali al-Akhnai Qazi al-Malikiyya and Istahbab Ziyarah, First Edition, Beirut: Al-Maktabeh al-Asriya.

- Ibn Taymiyyah al-Bahrani & Abd al-Rahman ibn Muhammad, (1433 AH), Al-Jawahir al-Bahir fi Zwar al-Maqbari, First Edition, Riyadh: Dar Al-Manhaj Library.

- Ibn Taymiyyah Al-Bahrani & Abd al-Rahman bin Muhammad, (1406 AH), Al-Manhaj Sunnah al-Nabiyyah, First Edition, Riyadh: Imam Muhammad bin Saud al-Islamiyya Jamia.

- Ibn Hajar Asqlani & Ahmad Ibn Ali, (1414 AH), Al-Darr al-Kamaneh Fi Ayan Al-Ma'e VIII, First Edition, Beirut: Dar al-Jeel.

- Ibn Abedin & Muhammad Amin, (1415 AH), Rejection of al-Muhthar, First Edition, Beirut: Dar al-Katb al-Alamiya.

- Ibn Ghannam, Hossein, (1403 AH), History of Najd, 1st Edition, Riyadh: Al-Safghat al-Zahabih.

- Bukhari, Abu Abdullah Muhammad B. Ismail, (1410 AH), Sahih Al-Bukhari, Second Edition, Qom: al-Maktabeh al-Salamiyyah al-Nashar wa al-Tawziyyah.

- Bin Baz & Abd al-Aziz, (1413 A.H.), Important Fatwa for the Whole Nation, First Edition, Riyadh: Dar al-Asma.

- Bin Baz, Abd al-Aziz, (1420 AH), Fatwa Collection, First Edition, Riyadh: Dar al-Qasim

- Bin Baz, Abdul Aziz, (1415 AH), Fatwa Collection of Bin Baz, Riyadh: Dartburiya Library

- Taftazani, Saad al-Din, (1421 AH), Sharh al-Aqeed al-Nasafiyyah and Maah al-Aqeed al-Nasafiyyah, Bija: Al-Maktab al-Azhariyyah for Traditions.

- Tahanwi, Ashraf Ali, (1430 AH), Imdad al-Fatawi, Karachi: Dar Uloom

- Sobhani, Jagar, (1385), Al-Wahabiyyah in Al-Mizan, First Edition, Qom: Educational and Research Institute of Imam Sadiq.

- Tayeb, Muhammad, (2009), Ulama of Deoband Aqeedah and Manhaja, First Edition, Deoband: Al-Jamieh al-Islamiyya.

- Abd al-Wahhab, Muhammad, (2016), Authors of Sheikh Muhammad bin Abd al-Wahhab, First Edition, Arabia: Society of Imam Muhammad bin Saud.

- Abd al-Wahhab, Muhammad, (1418 AH), Kashf al-Shabhat, First Edition, Riyadh: Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Endowment.

- Abd al-Wahab, Muhammad, (Bita), Risalat fay Alradu Aalay Alraafida, First Edition, Arabia: Imam Muhammad bin Saud Society.

- Qari, Mulla Ali, (1417 AH), Sharh al-Fiqh al-Kabar, First Edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Nafais

- Kothari, Mohammad Zahid, (2000), Kothari's Essays, First Edition, Egypt: Al-Maktabeh Al-Tawfiqah.

- Lahiji, Abd al-Razzaq, (1385), Shawariq Elham fi Sharh Tajrid al-Kalam, First Edition, Qom, Al-Imam Al-Sadiq Institute.

- Matridi, Abu Mansour, (Bita), Kitab al-Tawheed, Cairo: Dar al-Jamayat Al-Masriyyah

- Matridi, Abu Mansour, (1404 AH), Tawilat Ahle Sunnat, Haqqah and Rajih Muhammad Mustafiz al-Rahman, Baghdad: Al-Arshad Press.