Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 LLM, Political Science, Allameh Tabataba’i University, Tehran, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Political Sciences, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran

3 Associate Professor, Political Science, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Introduction
The constant tendency to focus on the people in the political arena can be seen among various groups in contemporary Iran, including the revolutionary leaders and groups focused on mobilizing the masses to confront the previous regime during the revolutionary movement, the rival revolutionary forces during the power struggle of the early years of the Islamic Revolution, and the leaders of the established government arising from the Islamic Revolution with the purpose of advancing their own domestic and foreign objectives and policies in the post-Revolutionary period. The main components of populism include the belief among political forces and leaders in the authenticity and righteousness of the unorganized masses and their direct mobilization in the field of politics as well as the appeal or pretension to redistribute resources among the masses. Thus, the question arises as to whether these components are only specific to some forces and leaders in the post-Revolutionary Iran, or more or less visible among all leaders and forces, regardless of the obvious differences in their political and ideological tendencies.
According to Dorraj (1990), Islamic populism is characterized by its religious character and  authoritarian, messianic, millenarian, and monistic nature coupled with revolutionary zest. Abrahamian (1993) refers to the non-religious and authoritarian populist nature of the state in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Kianpour (2006) views Ahmadinejad’s populism as a result of political representation suffering from the representativeness, or more precisely, a result of the problematic of impossibility and costliness of representing different political identities. Using Dornbusch and Edwards’ model, Farzanegan (2009) examines Ahmadinejad’s populism and finds it to be in accordance with the model. Having analyzed Keyhan and Etemad-e Melli newspapers, Zibakalam et al. (2013) conclude that Keyhan, more readily than Etemad-e Melli, pays attention to the categories supporting the populist discourse. For Farati (2013), populism originates from liberalism. Abdi (2014) considers populism to be a response to the short-term demands of people and a result of the contextual conditions and the increase in oil prices in Iran. Sarzaim (2016) views Ahmadinejad’s populism as the main reason for the lack of development during his presidency. Darvishpour (2022) considers the theory of contradictions of the populist revolution—which is based on critical theory, text analysis, discourse analysis, and post-structuralism—a useful theory in the evaluation of the Islamic Revolution.
The Purpose of Research
Attempting to investigate populism and politics in Iran during the post-Revolutionary years of 1989–2017, this research tries to show the common and distinctive features the political discourses, produced by various forces and in different periods, as manifested in the presidential speeches.
Methodology
The technique of documentation and the qualitative content analysis were used for data collection and data analysis, respectively. For the purpose of content analysis, several stages were followed: determining the content, determining the categories, determining the unit of analysis, coding, and conducting an analysis. The study considered the paragraph as the unit of analysis. The statistical population of the research consisted of all the speeches addressed by the presidents during their presidency. The sample population was also determined on the basis of systematic classification.
Findings
Concerning the political dimension of populism, 18, 16, 36, and 26 codes were identified in the speeches addressed by Hashemi-Rafsanjani, Khatami, Ahmadinjad, and Rouhani, respectively.  The most frequent code in Hashemi-Rafsanjani’s speech was related to militancy while participation of the marginalized masses, insufficiency of the political systems based solely on representativeness, consideration of himself as the real representative of people, simplicity and avoidance of political complications, and denial of the institutional mechanism were observed as having the equal weight in coding. Anti-elitism is the only component absent from Hashemi-Rafsanjani’s speeches. Concerning Khatami’s speeches, the political dimension of populism was mostly represented in the following components: participation of the marginalized masses, insufficiency of the political systems based solely on representativeness, simplicity and avoidance of political complications, consideration of himself as the real representative of people, and militancy. Anti-elitism and denial of the institutional mechanism were not observed in Khatami’s speeches. Militancy and simplicity and avoidance of political complications were, respectively, found to be the most and least frequent components in Khatami’s political populism. The political dimension of populism in Ahmadinejad’s speeches encompassed all the components, with militancy being the most frequent followed by simplicity and avoidance of political complications, denial of the institutional mechanism, and consideration of himself as the real representative of people. Rouhani also represented all these components, except anti-elitism. In the dimension of cultural populism, all the presidents used the component of admiration for national and religious values and heritage. All the components of the economic dimension were most frequently used by Ahmadinejad, except the component of distrust towards capitalist institutions and procedures. After Ahmadinejad, Rouhani frequently represented the economic dimension, but neither distrust towards capitalist institutions and procedures nor emphasis on income redistribution were found in Rouhani speeches. Among the five components of the economic dimension, Khatami and Hashemi-Rafsanjani only referred to the component of  fault-finding in the economic status quo. Concerning the social dimension of populism, Hashemi-Rafsanjani, Ahmadinejad, and Rouhani used all the relevant components, yet Khatami was found to have put no emphasis on the integration of society but on social pluralism.
Discussion and Conclusion
Owing to the nature of the Islamic Revolution that involved the masses in the political and social arenas, the politicians who came later to the scene had no choice but to tend towards the masses— though with varying degrees of intensity. The political society in Iran has experienced a kind of misunderstanding about populism for several years. This research worked well to show the inaccuracy of the dominant narrative in Iran, proving that populism is a spatiotemporal entity that differs from one society to another. Political leaders in Iran consider people wise and virtuous, and express it by various articulations. Yet the otherness figures differently among the presidents, depending on the circumstances of the time. Framing his articulations within the framework of Islam, Hashemi-Rafsanjani considered the right of the masses from the economic perspective by referring to the component of not encroaching on their rights. The otherness is depicted to be the hypocrites, the Pahlavi regime, and the administration of Mir Hossein Mousavi inside Iran, and the evil non-Islamic states outside the country. People were important to Hashemi-Rafsanjani in an unorganized way, and he considered the participation of the masses as a symbol of real democracy, thus showing little faith in institutions

Keywords

Main Subjects

  1. Abdi, Abbas, (2015), “Anyone in Ahmadinejad's Place Would have Done the Same Things”, Available at: https:// www. magiran. com/ article/3379177. [In Persian]
  2. -‌ Abrahamian, Eervand, (1993), Khomeinism: Essays on the Islamic Republic, University of California Press.
  3. -‌ Abrahamian, Eervand, (1998), Iran between Two Revolutions, Translated by Ahmad Gul Mohammadi and Mohammad Ebrahim Fatahi, Print 1, Tehran: Ney Publication. [In Persian]
  4. -‌ Ahmadinejad, Mahmoud, (2004), “Speech on the Inauguration Day of the First Term on August 3”, Retrieved on: April 6, 2016, citing the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  5. -‌ Ahmadinejad, Mahmoud, (2005), “Speech on the Day of the Execution of the Presidential Decree on August 6”, Retrieved on: April 21, 2016, citing the site: https:// www. president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  6. -‌ Ahmadinejad, Mahmoud, (2006), “Speech to Yasouj People on March 25”, Retrieved on: June 14, 2016, citing the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  7. -‌ Ahmadinejad, Mahmoud, (2007), “Speech on the Day of the Ceremony on 11 February”, Retrieved on: February 13, 2016, citing the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  8. -‌ Ahmadinejad, Mahmoud, (2007), “Speech to the People of Shiraz on April 16”, Retrieved on: February 15, 2016, citing the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  9. -‌ Ahmadinejad, Mahmoud, (2009), “Speech on the Day of the Ceremony on 10 February”, retrieved on: February 15, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive .[In Persian]
  10. - Albertazzi, Daneile & McDonnell, Duncan, (2008), Twenty-First Century Populism, PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York.
  11. -‌ Arditi, Benjamín (2004), “Populism as a Spectre of Democracy: A Response to Canovan”, Political Studies, Vol. 52, pp 135–143.
  12. - Aristotle, (2011), Politics, Translated by Hamid Enayat, Tehran: Amir Kabir. [In Persian]
  13. -‌ Barnes, Harry Elmer; Becker, Howard, (1991), History of Social Thought from Early Society to Modern Society, Translated by Javad Yousefian and Ali Asghar Majidi, Tehran: Amir Kabir. [In Persian]
  14. - ­Barr, Robert R, (2009), “Populists, Outsiders and Anti-Establishment Polotics”, Party Politics, Los Angeles, Vol. 15, pp 29-48.
  15. - Beresser-Pereira, L.C.B, (1991), “Populism and Economic Policy in Brazil”, Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs, Vol. 33, No. 2.
  16. - Berlin, Isaiah, (1968), “To Define Populism”, The Isaiah Berlin Literary Trust 2013, Retrieved 2017, Dec, 2. PP 1-19, From: http:// berlin. wolf.ox.ac.uk.
  17. - Canovan, Margaret, (1999), “Trust the People! Populism and the Tow Faces of Democracy”, Political Studies, XLVII, pp 2-16.
  18. - Collier, Ruth Berins, )2001(, “Populism” In N. Smelser and P. Baltes, eds., International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Science, 17: 11813–16. New York: Elsevier.
  19. -‌ Dahl, Robert, (1999), About Democracy, Translated by Hasan Shaharaki, Tehran, Shirazeh. [In Persian]
  20. -‌ Daraj, Manouchehr, (1990), From Zoroastrianism to Khomeini's Religious Sectarianism in Iran, England: Ranier. [In Persian]
  21. -‌ Daraj, Manouchehr, (2017), From Zoroaster to Khomeini (Populism and Unification in Iran), translated by Farrokhzad Farzin Zand, Tehran: Par Cultural Institute. [In Persian]
  22. -‌ Darvishpour, Mehrdad, (2021), “Transition from Populist Revolution to Islamic Revolution”, accessible at:  https:// pecritique. files. wordpress. com/ 2021/ 04/ mehrdad- darvishpour- transition- from-populist-to-islamic-revolution.pdf. [In Persian]
  23. - Dornbusch, Rudiger & Edwards, Sebastian, (1990), The Macroeconomics of Populism in Latin America, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  24. - Farati, Abdul Wahab, (2013), Populism, Tehran: Young Thought Center. [In Persian]
  25. -‌ Farzanegan, Mohammad Reza, (2009), Macroeconomic of Populism in Iran, Munich Personal RePEc Archive, University Library of Munich, Germany.
  26. -‌ Hashemi Rafsanjani, Akbar, (1989), “Speech on the Day of the Execution of the Presidential Decree on August 17”, retrieved on October 29, 2016, Quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  27. - Hashemi Rafsanjani, Akbar, (1989), “Speech on the Inauguration Day on August 3”, Retrieved on October 25, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  28. -‌ Hashemi Rafsanjani, Akbar, (1990), “Speech to the People of Mashhad on June 14”, retrieved on November 4, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  29. -‌ Hashemi Rafsanjani, Akbar, (1991), “Speech on the Day of the Ceremony on 11 February”, Retrieved on December 11, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  30. -‌ Hashemi Rafsanjani, Akbar, (1991), “Speech to the People of Shiraz on April 18’, retrieved on November 27, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  31. - Hashemi Rafsanjani, Akbar, (1993), “Speech on the Day of the Ceremony on 10 February”, retrieved on December 23, 2016, quoted from the site: https:// www. president. ir/f a/Archive. [In Persian]
  32. -‌ Hashemi, Ahmad, (2021), “Government Populism in Iran and the Face of Populism in a Range of Overseas Opposition”, available in: https://www.akhbar-rooz. com/ 108899/ 1400/01/13/. [In Persian]
  33. - Jakobson, Mari-Liis, (2012), Populism in the Baltic States, Avatud Eesti Fond Open Estonia Foundation.
  34. - Jansen, Robert S, (2011), “Populist Mobilization: A New Theoretical Approach to Populism”, Sociological Theory, American Sociological Association, Volume. 29, Issue. 2, Pages 75–96.
  35. - Johansson, Andreas, (2016), Authoritarian Populism Index, Gothenburg: Timbro.
  36. -‌ Khatami, Seyed Mohammad, (1997), “Speech on the Day of the Execution of the Presidential Decree on August 4”, Retrieved on May 12, 2016, citing the site: https:// www. president. ir/ fa/Archive [In Persian]
  37. -‌ Khatami, Seyed Mohammad, (1997), “Speech on the Inauguration Day on August 3”, retrieved on May 12, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  38. -‌ Khatami, Seyed Mohammad, (1998), “Speech to the People of Zahedan on April 1st”, retrieved on May 19, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  39. -‌ Khatami, Seyed Mohammad, (1999), “Speech on the Day of the Ceremony on 11 February”, retrieved on May 25, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  40. -‌ Khatami, Seyed Mohammad, (1999), “Speech to the People of Khorramabad on 14 April”, retrieved on June 17, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  41. -‌ Khatami, Seyed Mohammad, (2001), “Speech on the Day of the Ceremony on 10 February”, Retrieved on July 24, 2016, citing the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  42. - Kianpour, Amir, (2016), “Reviewing the Status of Populism”, Dialogue Cultural and Social Quarterly, No. 49, pp. 83-88. [In Persian]
  43. - Kornhauser, W, (1959), The Politics of Mass Society, New York Free Press.
  44. -‌ Lance, Justin (2009), “Americanism and Populism in Latin America”, translated by F. M. Hashemi, Chista Monthly, No. 261, August. [In Persian]
  45. - Lipsett, Seymour Martin [and colleagues], (2004), Encyclopedia of Democracy, Translated by a Group of Translators Under the Supervision of Kamran Fani and Nurullah Moradi, Tehran: Office of Political and International Studies of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. [In Persian]
  46. -‌ Mahdavian, Hadi, (2006), “The Fever of Populism, the Coldness of Reality”, Economic Trend, May, No. 32, from pages 1 to 10. [In Persian]
  47. - Muller, Jan Werner, (2016), What is Populism? Translated by Babak Vahedi, Tehran: Bidgol Publishing. [In Persian]
  48. -‌ Pappas, T, (2013a), “Why Greece Failed”, Journal of Democracy, Vol. 24, No. 2.
  49. - Robert Kahn, Steven A, (2015), “Addressing Economic Populism in Europe”, Council on Foreign Relations, Center for Geoeconomic Studies.
  50. -‌ Rokkan S. & Urbwin, (1973), Bulding State and Nation, Berekly: Hills
  51. - Rouhani, Hassan, (2013), “Speech on the Day of the Execution of the Presidential Decree on August 3”. retrieved on July 31, 2016, quoted from the site: https:// www. president. ir/ fa/ Archive. [In Persian]
  52. -‌ Rouhani, Hassan, (2013), “Speech on the Inauguration Day on August 2”, Retrieved on July 26, 2016, Quoted from the Site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  53. -‌ Rouhani, Hassan, (2014), “Speech to the People of Zahedan Day on April 15”, Retrieved on August 5, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  54. -‌ Rouhani, Hassan, (2015), “Speech on the Day of the Ceremony on 11 February”. Retrieved on August 31, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  55. -‌ Rouhani, Hassan, (2015), “Speech to the People of Gilan Day on April 16”, Retrieved on August 24, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  56. -‌ Rouhani, Hassan, (2017), “Speech on the Day of the Ceremony on 10 February”, Retrieved on August 16, 2016, quoted from the site: https://www.president.ir/fa/Archive. [In Persian]
  57. -‌ Sarzaeem, Ali, (2016), Iranian Populism, Tehran: Kargaden Publishing. [In Persian]
  58. -‌ Strinati, Dominic, (2001), Introduction to Popular Culture Theories, Translated by Masoumeh Jamshidi, Tehran: Game Nou, Second Edition. [In Persian]
  59. -‌ Taggart, Paul (2002), Populism, Translated by Hasan Mortazavi, Tehran: Ashian Publishing House. [In Persian]
  60. - Tilly, Charles, (1978), From Mobilization to Revolution, California: McGraw-Hill.
  61. - Torres, Vladimir, (2006), The Impact of Populism on Social, Political, and Economic Development in the Hemisphere, Policy Paper Document Politique, Retrieve, Ottawa: Focal.
  62. -‌ Zibakalam, Sadeq; Soltanifar, Mohammad & Mirzakhanian, Ani, (2017), “Investigation of the Function of Written Media in the Creation and Spread of Populism in Iran”, Communication Culture Quarterly, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 35-53. [In Persian]